Intermission (personal commentary)

Today, I saw the kickstarter for Comics Undressed, a documentary about the gender and racial discrimination in comics.  If you think it’s a worthy endeavor, totally contribute to the cause because they deserve to have this documentary made.  But while I agree completely with their notion that comics are dominated by mainly white men, I believe they’re missing a vital perspective of their argument.  Full disclosure: I am a white man.  As they state on their website:

Comics, heralded as a white heterosexual masculine medium, has in fact a diverse range of contributors, many of whom are women, non-white, and/or do not conform to the binary constructs of sexual or gender identity. However, such voices often go unrecognized or are demeaned in mainstream media. Moreover, the lack of equal economic opportunities for a wide range of creators stifles the output of our culturally diverse society, which in turn is reflected in negative or absent portrayals of women, queers, and people of color in the content of the medium itself.

Like I said, I’m not arguing about the people creating the comics themselves, but I do have a point to make about the lack of non-white, female, or gay characters populating comics today.  And it comes down to the notion that as creative, artistic, and passionate comics are, they are (and always will be) first and foremost a business.  Look, here’s the most recent Justice League lineup from the New 52:


Yes, one woman and one African-American.  Zero gay men or women.  But you realize why, right?  All those white male straight superheroes have been around for 60 to 70 years.  We grew up immersed in Superman, Batman, Green Lantern, Flash, and Aquaman.  And unfortunately, those are also the characters that sell the best.  We can protest all we want, but comics are essentially adolescent in nature, and the audience of comics will almost always be made up of mostly teenage boys.  They love Superman.  They love Batman.  And they love skimpy outfits.

We shouldn’t be focusing on a “comics hate women, minorities, and homosexuals” because victimizing won’t accomplish our goal.  Instead, we need to focus our energy entirely on how to get teenage boys to buy comics starring women, minorities, and homosexuals.

It’s insane to think Marvel and DC are misogynistic, racist, homophobic companies.  You don’t really believe that, do you?  But I do know that as much as they want diversity to spread to their artistic medium, they want to make money more.  Business first and foremost.  If they believe a Superman movie will make more money than a Wonder Woman movie, well, you know what they’ll choose.  It’s not about diversity or agenda, it’s about profit.  We can’t hate them because of how capitalism operates.

I completely and totally support what the Comics Undressed documentary wishes to show the world, but the problem solves itself in one simple step: readers buy more comics starring women, minorities, and homosexuals and more comics starring women, minorities, and homosexuals will be available. The problem has never been the industry.  It’s always been the audience.  If that’s the main argument of Comics Undressed and not the victimization angle, then I take back what I say.

Thank you for indulging me.  Tomorrow we’ll cover another white man, and I apologize in advance.

3 Comments on “Intermission (personal commentary)”

  1. biggestfan says:

    i really agree with you, on this, but when i see a gay comic book character doing, well gay things it’s weird because you expect them to be manly and straight and have a girlfriend that gets killed in later issues, don’t get me wrong i don’t have a problem with gay people (i’m only saying gay cuz i don’t want to take the time out to spell homosexual) but it kinda ruins the stereotype for comics, take green lantern of earth 2 the new 52 when he has a boyfriend named sam that tainted the image of green lantern for ever to me but women and minorities need to be made more popular (partly because i’m black) well i have said my piece get back to me
    p.s your blogs are great keep them coming

  2. Jason says:

    We scarcely see comic characters getting into their smalls because their primary role is to act as heroes fighting against evil doers. From that perspective it doesn’t matter what their “preference” is.

    Also, as you say, if comic book readers wanted homosexual characters the comic companies would provide them.

    Still working on that Death of Daken story I offered to write a while back. Just struggling to come up with a scenario in which someone armed with “bone” claws could ever be considered a real threat. Certainly Daken’s defeat of Frank Castle was a practical impossibility. I guess I’ll write it “realistically” and depict him losing to a guy armed with a pocket knife.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s